From the Trading Desk. Shares the trading desk is selling, avoiding, and waiting to see if it corrects.
Jollibee Foods Corporation (JFC) is the undisputed leader in Philippine quick-service dining. With over 3,400 stores locally and decades of dominance, JFC is a mature company by every textbook measure:
- High market penetration in its home market
- Stable cash flows from a loyal customer base
- Ability to pay consistent dividends—a hallmark of maturity
In fact, one defining trait of mature firms is a high dividend yield, reflecting limited reinvestment opportunities and a shift toward rewarding shareholders. Yet JFC’s current strategy tells a different story.
The Growth Narrative
Instead of leaning into its maturity, JFC is chasing a growth-company image through aggressive acquisitions and international expansion. Tim Ho Wan (premium dim sum), Compose Coffee (South Korea), CBTL, Highlands Coffee, Smashburger—the list is long and expensive. These deals inflate goodwill (₱78.7B as of Q3 2025) and create headlines, but they don’t guarantee earnings accretion.
Tim Ho Wan, acquired for ₱10.7B in January 2025, posted a ₱86.9M net loss in its first nine months under JFC. Older acquisitions like CBTL and Smashburger were loss-making for years. Even with Compose Coffee’s success (₱1.59B net income in 9M 2025), the overall picture is clear: acquisition losses and financing costs are eating into the profits of JFC’s core Philippine business.
The Cost of Pretending
Despite a 14% revenue surge in 9M 2025, net income grew only 1.6%. Why? Debt-funded acquisitions and integration costs. JFC issued senior notes and ramped up short-term borrowings to finance these deals, adding interest expense that drags on earnings.
This raises a critical question: Should JFC embrace its maturity instead of masking it? A pivot toward higher dividends—even a REIT-like yield—could unlock value for investors seeking income stability rather than speculative growth.
A Dividend-Focused Strategy
If JFC accepted its mature status, here’s what it could do:
-
Reframe capital allocation
- Pause high-risk acquisitions and focus on optimizing existing brands.
- Use free cash flow to pay down debt and reduce interest drag.
-
Target a REIT-like dividend yield
- Aim for 4–6% annual yield, with a 60–70% payout ratio of normalized net income.
- Commit to quarterly dividends for predictability.
- At a hypothetical ₱200 share price, a ₱8–₱12 annual dividend would rival REITs.
-
Build an income investor narrative
- Position JFC as a stable cash generator, not a speculative growth stock.
- Highlight recurring cash flows from franchising and royalties.
-
Enhance shareholder returns
- Consider special dividends from divesting underperforming brands.
- Deploy share buybacks when valuation dips below intrinsic value.
The Verdict
JFC is not “pretending” in a deceptive sense—it genuinely wants global scale. But the reality is stark: its domestic engine is mature, and its growth bets are risky and uneven. Until acquisitions deliver consistent profits, JFC looks less like a growth stock and more like a cash-rich incumbent stretching for relevance.
If the market recalibrates expectations, JFC’s share price could correct to reflect a high-yield, income-oriented profile, rewarding investors who value stability over uncertain expansion.
Comments
Post a Comment