the Outsider - PSE Points to Ponder

Posts

After PCIBank: The Diverging Fortunes of the Lopezes and the Gokongweis

Two former allies sold a bank together. Their heirs now offer a study in how family capitalism can fail in opposite ways. Kapitan Geny Lopez and John Gokongwei were once close business allies in the practical, old-Philippine-capitalism sense of the term: at PCIBank, Mr Lopez served as chairman, Mr Gokongwei as vice-chairman, and the two families were widely understood to be the bank’s principal shareholders and decision-makers before its sale in 1999. Their joint exit, part of a record-setting ₱31.9bn transaction that led to Equitable PCI Bank, looked at the time like a textbook redeployment of capital—an elegant retreat from banking into supposedly more strategic pursuits. In retrospect, that sale reads less like an ending than a fork in the road. Both clans have since run into trouble in the pet businesses of their forefathers: ABS-CBN for the Lopezes, petrochemicals for the Gokongweis. Both businesses carry the emotional charge that only founding projects do. Yet the sim...

What the Feuding Lopezes Are Still Arguing About, the Gokongweis Already Did: Borrow Heavily, Rescue JGSOC, Then Record a ₱169.2 Billion Impairment

A holding company that collected billions in dividends, borrowed heavily, and still found itself pouring money into a subsidiary it would soon have to gut Conglomerates are meant to be shock absorbers. When one business stumbles, the others carry it. Cash from food, property, and mature investments is supposed to steady the weak leg of the empire until the cycle turns. In 2025, JG Summit Holdings’ parent company discovered the limits of that idea. The parent collected ₱19.604 billion in dividends in 2025. Under normal circumstances, that would have been the sort of number that justifies a holding-company discount: real cash extracted from a sprawling portfolio, available for debt service, redeployment or distributions to shareholders. But 2025 was not normal. The same parent-company cash-flow statement shows ₱45.633 billion of additional investments in subsidiaries . The dividends were not enough even to cover the cash rescue, much less the parent’s operating cash burn. The parent al...

Lucio Co's Liquor House Has a Banker’s Balance Sheet

For a distributor of spirits, The Keepers Holdings looks surprisingly sober on paper. Sales are rising, cash generation is strong, and, most strikingly, money parked in short-term instruments is already enough to extinguish the group’s entire trade-and-other-payables line. The worry is not solvency. It is margin. In the liquor business, glamour tends to sit on the label while risk lurks in the warehouse. Importers and distributors live with working-capital demands, fickle consumer tastes and the occasional ambush from foreign exchange. The Keepers Holdings, the Philippine drinks distributor behind a portfolio dominated by Alfonso brandy, finished 2025 with none of the harried look that often accompanies growth in consumer goods. Total assets rose to ₱23.26 billion , equity climbed to ₱19.22 billion and total liabilities stood at a modest ₱4.04 billion ; the company’s debt-to-equity ratio was just 0.21 times , while its current ratio remained a lofty 4.48 times . That is the lang...

Consunji’s Semirara saw operating cash flow fall 40% in 2025 as shareholders await the usual March–April dividend

A coal-and-power cash machine is still throwing off money. Just not quite as extravagantly as before. There is a difference in business between earning less and feeling poorer. Semirara Mining and Power Corporation, the Philippines’ coal baron with captive power plants strapped to its side, managed both in 2025. Reported net income fell to about ₱13.1bn , down a third from the year before. More tellingly, operating cash flow slid to roughly ₱16.4bn from ₱27.5bn —a drop of about 40% . In a company whose investment case has long rested on fat, frequent cash distributions, that is the number that stings. Profits flatter; cash pays dividends. That distinction matters because Semirara is not merely a cyclical resource stock. It has become, in the minds of many local investors, a sort of irregular annuity: a company that pays in spring, and often surprises again in autumn. In 2025 , it still declared dividends of ₱13.8bn , lower than the ₱25.5bn distributed in 2024 but still ge...

Manny Pangilinan Uses IPO to Fortify Maynilad’s Balance Sheet

In most emerging markets, utilities are valued for their predictability. They collect monthly bills, raise tariffs only after a fight, and borrow prodigiously in the hope that investors will mistake ballast for glamour. Maynilad Water Services, newly listed on the Philippine Stock Exchange in November 2025, is trying to prove that a water monopoly can be both dull and ambitious at once: a regulated utility with the instincts of an infrastructure developer. Its 2025 annual report reads like the ledger of a company that has just acquired a larger sense of itself. The IPO brought fresh capital and public scrutiny; the operating business delivered sturdy growth; yet the central question remains whether today’s vast investment program will one day yield stronger cash flow, higher returns, and better per-share economics. Maynilad begins from an enviable position. It serves what it describes as the largest water concession in Southeast Asia, covering 540 square kilometers across M...

"Poison pill" or "Key-man"?: Did Piki Lopez let Razon’s flattery cloud his fiduciary duty?

First Gen’s “poison pill” may be dressed up as a key-man clause. But for investors, its real meaning is simpler: the company has tied billions of pesos of shareholder value to the continued primacy of one executive in the middle of an active family power struggle. Enrique Razon Jr’s compliment to Federico “Piki” Lopez was flattering enough. Prime Infrastructure, First Gen says, insisted on a “change of management control” clause because it trusted Mr. Lopez and his team to execute two large pumped-storage hydro projects safely, efficiently, and on schedule. First Gen has even cast the arrangement as a “vote of confidence” from Mr. Razon — proof, in effect, that the company’s leadership was indispensable. Yet the test of fiduciary responsibility is not whether a chief executive is admired by a counterparty. It is whether he converts that admiration into terms that protect the owners of the company he serves. On that standard, First Gen’s defense of its so-called poison pill ...